The question
The story is intuitive: conflict raises expectations of military spending, so defense contractors should outperform. I wanted to know whether the data actually supports that.
Method
- Sample: 7 defense contractors, compared against the S&P 500
- Events: 3 geopolitical conflicts
- Window: ±90 days around each event
- Tests: hypothesis tests on pre- versus post-event returns, plus difference-in-differences against the market
Result
No statistically significant evidence of consistent outperformance (p = 0.516).
That doesn't mean conflicts never move defense stocks. It means that, across these events, outperformance wasn't reliable enough to trade on.
What I learned
Three claims are easy to mix up: a stock went up, a stock beat the market, and an event caused it to beat the market. A persuasive narrative can sound like all three while supporting only the first.